Expert Blogs

Where experts share

Holdover or Autonomy?

By Cath Bartlett on
Cath Bartlett
Cath Bartlett has not set their biography yet
User is currently offline
Mar 25 in Cold chain equipment and cold chain equipment management 2 Comments

When considering which solar vaccine fridge to buy, do purchasers use the results of autonomy or holdover tests to inform their decision?

In the WHO PQS test protocol, the holdover test measures performance of the appliance without any power supply, whilst the autonomy test looks at the performance with a reduced (5%) power supply. For Solar Direct Drive fridges (without ancillary batteries), autonomy testing is a requirement even though the 5% power supplied during the testing period is inadequate to power the compressor, nor is it used to power any additional cooling device such as a fan or flaps.

 The protocols for autonomy and holdover testing in these appliances are identical in most respects with the exception of temperature: temperature is at intervals of one minute until the warmest point in the load exceeds 8oC in the autonomy test or 10oC in the holdover test. The major difference between the two tests is that there is a 5% power supply to the appliance during the autonomy test, which in this type of appliance, does not affect the cooling in any way.

 Where long holdover times at high ambient temperatures have already been established, what additional advantage, from the customer’s point of view, do the results of such autonomy tests confer?

Tags: refrigeration equipment, cold chain equipment
Hits: 1011
3 votes

Trackbacks

Trackback URL for this blog entry
  • acheter

    by acheter on Tuesday, 30 November 1999
    Holdover or Autonomy? - Expert Blogs ...
  • spanish courses for teaching qualification

    by spanish courses for teaching qualification on Tuesday, 30 November 1999
    Holdover or Autonomy? - Expert Blogs ...
  • 24 hour appliance repair service

    by 24 hour appliance repair service on Tuesday, 30 November 1999
    Holdover or Autonomy? - Expert Blogs ...
  • pencil drawings

    by pencil drawings on Tuesday, 30 November 1999
    Holdover or Autonomy? - Expert Blogs ...

Comments

Toryalai Hart
Toryalai Hart
British-American, born in Afghanistan, grew up in West Africa and have set foot
User is currently offline
Toryalai Hart Tuesday, 24 May 2011

I would take both into account

If I were specifying equipment for a project, I would seek out a balance between autonomy and holdover, thus leading to maximum reliability for the lowest cost while distributing the risk of failure across technologies.

ian.tansley
ian.tansley
ian.tansley has not set their biography yet
User is currently offline
ian.tansley Wednesday, 27 July 2011

There is no such thing as Autonomy in a battery free refrigerator

The concepts of holdover and autonomy have been borrowed from the old battery powered solar fridges and to my mind don’t have a place in the new world free of unreliable batteries.
There is some confusion as traditionally 'holdover' was a measure of the fridge's ability to maintain temperature on its own (with the power supply disconnected) and 'Autonomy' was the length of time the battery storage could support the fridge.
In the absence of the battery there is only one figure and by the definitions above, that must be the holdover. It is somewhat distracting to talk about autonomy with respect to Battery-free refrigerators especially when what was really meant was 'how long can you keep the fridge running by giving it just enough power to keep its temperature control system running'. This concept was invented for one specific technology and thankfully we're well past needing to rely on that now.
I say let's stick to 'Holdover' and do away with Autonomy for solar direct drive units.

Please login first in order for you to submit comments

Latest Blog Comments

Rahman Olasunkanmi Kelani
  Thanks Tory for this beautiful piece. I totally agree with you. there are no complexities, the presidents are the commander in chief of armed forces, and the employer of the minister of healths. These  
ian.tansley
  I think this is a great idea. It's unfortunate that you jump immediately ahead to solar only sites as the vast majority of sites are still powered exclusively using diesel generators. Most of the ti  
ian.tansley
  The concepts of holdover and autonomy have been borrowed from the old battery powered solar fridges and to my mind don’t have a place in the new world free of unreliable batteries. There is some conf  
Mohammad Tiu
  Informative post!Bill Gates and his wife Melinda's engagement to the different charity events is one of the calls that caught my interest to read this article. To be immunized of vaccine is one of the  
Toryalai Hart
  Wow James - Thanks for this fascinating post, particularly about the freeze drying of smallpox vaccine. Unfortunately, at least in W-Africa, storage rooms are typically built of cement blocks with a  
Toryalai Hart
  Corporate CSR is indeed an interesting angle but likely would prove complex if they were doing anything more than helping with cold chain logistics and storage? Some work is already being done on thi  
Ranjit Dhiman
  Thanks Tory for this nice initiative and great example of support to immunization programs. I believe it is time for countries to revisit the strategy of making and owning the infrastructure in terms  
Toryalai Hart
  If I were specifying equipment for a project, I would seek out a balance between autonomy and holdover, thus leading to maximum reliability for the lowest cost while distributing the risk of failure a  

Terms and Conditions

TechNet21 is generously supported by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, under the oversight of WHO and UNICEF. The information in this forum is provided by users, as a service. All contributions are reviewed prior to posting, and all postings are attributed to the authors. The details given in emails will not be voluntarily shared or sold to any outside company and will only be used for verification and to identify postings, if necessary. The authors are solely responsible for their submissions, and the readers are solely responsible for the interpretation of these submissions. In no event shall the World Health Organization be liable for any damages arising from the use of the information linked to this forum. For posts where the author is a WHO staff member, the author alone is responsible for the views expressed and they do not necessarily represent the decisions, guidelines, recommendations or policies of WHO.